MagnaChip Announces Completion of Audit Committee's Investigation; Update on Restatement Process
The Company previously reported that as a result of the preliminary findings of the Investigation, the Company's financial statements for each of the fiscal years ended
Legal counsel engaged by the Audit Committee to conduct the Investigation, with the assistance of outside forensic accountants, has recently reported to the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors that the Investigation, which began in
As previously announced, the Investigation had found that the Company incorrectly recognized revenue on certain transactions when products were shipped to a distributor; such revenue should have been recognized when the distributor shipped the product to the customer. In addition, the Investigation identified the following, among other, undisclosed business practices at the Company's Korean subsidiary (the Company's principal operating entity), that involved a lack of adequate controls and procedures:
- various manufacturing-related business practices that facilitated premature revenue recognition on unfinished goods, semi-finished goods, and inventory manufactured in advance that affected revenue and sales targets;
- various sales practices that resulted in overstated revenue for particular reporting periods, including premature shipment of products to and pulled-in orders from distributors and customers at quarter end;
- cash payments to certain vendors, using expense and capital expenditure accounts at the Company, that (i) the vendors used to purchase products from certain distributors; (ii) the distributors then paid to the Company for those products; and (iii) in turn were applied to aged accounts receivable;
- various improper inventory reserve accounting, non-recurring engineering (NRE) accounting, warranty reserve accounting and capitalization of repair expenses as capital expenditures that affected gross margins;
- improper allocations of selling, general, and administrative costs ("SG&A") that understated such costs and smoothed the SG&A-to-revenue ratio trend;
- improper deferral of outsourcing and free sample expenses that smoothed expense trends;
- improper revenue recognition on a gross rather than net basis for certain products and customers; and
- various undisclosed business practices and related concessions for distributors and customers (including credit limit increases, payment term extensions, provision of free samples, future discounts, and stock rotations), with distributor and customer consent, that affected the Company's sales.
The materials reviewed during the Investigation did not reveal any evidence that the Company's Audit Committee, the current directors, or the Company's independent registered public accounting firm, Samil PricewaterhouseCoopers ("Samil PwC"), were aware of the undisclosed business practices described above.
In addition to the Investigation, management of the Company has also concurrently undertaken a comprehensive review of the Company's accounting practices during the restatement periods in connection with the preparation of restated financial statements, including a Company-wide review of its revenue recognition practices and policies, and to date has identified certain additional errors and adjustments that it expects to correct as part of the restatement. When completed, the restatement will correct the accounting errors that were identified during the Investigation and review process. Due to the ongoing nature of the Company's internal review and restatement process, the Company cannot at this time provide an estimate of the individual or net effect of these errors and adjustments for any given period, but currently expects that the impact of some of the adjustments on certain periods in the restatement periods will be material. The Company's management and its outside advisors continue to evaluate and review the various types of errors and adjustments that have been identified as of the date of this release, and these adjustments are subject to change until the Company completes its restatement of its financial statements. Additional errors or adjustments may be identified prior to the completion of the restatement, some or all of which may be material to the Company's financial statements.
As a result of the accounting and other issues identified by management and the Investigation, management has concluded that one or more material weaknesses exist in the Company's internal control over financial reporting and that, as a result, the Company's disclosure controls and procedures were not effective as of the end of each of the restatement periods, and that the Company did not maintain effective internal control over financial reporting as of
While the Company has not yet completed its assessment of disclosure controls and procedures and internal control over financial reporting for the restatement periods, the Company has already initiated a number of remedial measures that are ongoing in response to the Investigation, including:
- the development of more detailed revenue recognition practices and policies, including consideration for sales and payment discounts, price protections, returns, stock rotation, samples, payment terms and credit limit extensions;
- the strengthening of the accounting, finance and internal audit teams with additional personnel with extensive US GAAP experience;
- the strengthening of overall controls and disclosure processes and systems;
- implementing financial accounting and reporting literacy training for the accounting, finance, internal audit and sales teams, including acceptable business practices;
- the enhancement of enterprise resource planning reporting to highlight changes in exceptions or sales terms and to prohibit the manual acceleration of inventory through the manufacturing process;
- the building of an overall culture of compliance and establishment of a compliance office; and
- the development of distributor inventory policy, process and system controls.
Following the Company's initial announcement of the restatement in
The Company is continuing the process of completing the preparation, review and audit of its financial statements for its fiscal year ended
Subject to management's completion of the restated financial statements and related disclosures for the restatement periods as well as the reviews and audit to be conducted by Samil PwC, the Company currently anticipates filing its 2013 Form 10-K by
About
Headquartered in
Safe Harbor for Forward-Looking Statements
Information in this release regarding MagnaChip's forecasts, business outlook, expectations and beliefs are forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 that involve risks and uncertainties. All forward-looking statements included in this release, including expectations about the timing, form and content of the Company's 2013 Form 10-K and other
CONTACTS:
In
Director of Investor Relations
Tel. +1-408-625-1262
robert.pursel@magnachip.com
SOURCE